Water Testing

Coliform and E. coli Water Testing: Colilert vs. Membrane Filtration

By Ramo Trading 3 min read

Chemical tests tell you whether water is treated correctly. Microbiological tests tell you whether it is safe to drink. Drinking water regulations worldwide rely on total coliforms and E. coli as indicator organisms. Total coliforms point to possible contamination or a problem with treatment. E. coli specifically indicates fecal contamination.

Two methods dominate routine testing: enzyme substrate tests, best known as IDEXX Colilert, and classic membrane filtration.

IDEXX Colilert-18 coliform and E. coli test
IDEXX Colilert-18
Hach sterile 47 mm membrane filters
Sterile 47 mm membrane filters

Method 1: IDEXX Colilert enzyme substrate testing

Colilert uses nutrient indicators that coliforms and E. coli metabolize. After incubation, a yellow color shows total coliforms are present. Fluorescence under UV light shows E. coli. Colilert-18 gives results in 18 hours.

Advantages: minimal sample preparation, no media to make up, easy to read, and well suited to labs with limited microbiology experience.

What you need:

For counts instead of presence/absence, Colilert can be combined with IDEXX Quanti-Tray to give a most probable number (MPN).

Method 2: Membrane filtration

A measured volume of sample is drawn through a sterile membrane with a 0.45 µm pore size, which traps the bacteria. The membrane is placed on a selective growth medium and incubated, and the characteristic colonies are counted.

Advantages: direct colony counts, the ability to filter large sample volumes for very clean water, and flexibility to test other organisms by changing the medium.

What you need:

Which method should you choose?

Factor Colilert Membrane filtration
Ease of use Very easy Requires aseptic technique
Hands-on time Low Moderate
Result type P/A, or MPN with Quanti-Tray Direct colony count
Large sample volumes Limited Excellent
Turbid samples Handles well Can clog filters

Many labs use both: Colilert for routine compliance samples and membrane filtration for special investigations.

Good practice for any microbiology test

  • Use sterile containers that contain sodium thiosulfate when sampling chlorinated water.
  • Keep samples cool and test them within the holding time your method allows.
  • Run positive and negative controls.
  • Confirm incubator temperatures every day and keep the records.

Supplies from Ramo Trading

We supply IDEXX reagents, Hach microbiology consumables, and the incubators, autoclaves and lab equipment to run them. Request a quote for your lab.

Comments (0)

Comments are reviewed before they're published.

Related articles